Vacation rentals in Sandy Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sandy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Surf City

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

All New, Top 5% Rated by Guests, Covered Decks

2025 Summer Weeks Are Up (Saturday check in)!...Fall/Winter Weekends/Weekdays available. Please Inquire for Best pricing. *3 BR, 5 Beds (Nectar Mattress in Master BR), Full Washer/Dryer, Outside Shower, Gas Grill * Covered Deck with Furniture for outdoor Dining even in Rain w Lights * Super Fast Wifi 373+MBS * High Water Pressure Showers * Walk to several eateries * 6 Beach Badges & 4 Chairs included * Parking Onsite 4 Cars Professionally cleaned 91% Alcohol and Bleach for all Touch Surfaces.

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Mount Holly

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Full in-law suite w/ amenities in a historic town

A quaint, stylish home in historic Mount Holly, walking distance from downtown pubs, museums and shops. Pet friendly with ample street parking, fully functional kitchen, full size refrigerator with ice maker, private bathroom (separate toilet and shower). Semi-private laundry / utility room, only used by owners to access the garage. Broadband WiFi included as well as a 65" LED TV with a wide range of streaming apps. A quaint patio area in the front yard invites guests to enjoy the weather.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Stafford Township

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 287 reviews

Cozy Cottage on the Lagoon

Kick back and relax on the lagoon with easy access to the bay by kayak or boat. The beautiful beaches of LBI are just over the bridge, less then 4 miles away. You can ride your bike to the beach. Start your day with coffee out by the lagoon or a kayak/paddle board ride. Spend the day sunbathing, reading a book or fishing. Grill at home in our fully stocked cabana or head out to one of the fantastic restaurants on LBI. As the sun set enjoy drinks and roasted marshmallows by the fire pit.

Superhost

Rental unit in Harvey Cedars

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Maiden Lane Hideaway

Spacious studio 1 block from both the beach and bay in the heart of Harvey Cedars on Long Beach Island, NJ. Walk to restaurants, markets, ice cream, bar, liquor store and firehouse which hosts fun community events. Rental includes a coffee maker, blender, microwave, basic dishes, flatware. Sunny hideaway has a private patio, grill, two private entrances, access to an outside shower. Great couples retreat. Grab your surfboard, kayak, bicycles, beach bag and relax in this inviting environment.

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Hammonton

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 289 reviews

The Little House

The Little House is a quaint place to stay during your time in the South Jersey area while visiting friends/family, wineries & breweries, the beaches or the city of Philadelphia - also close to the soccer fields that host many East Coast leagues. The Little House is perfect for a business traveler, couple or an adult & child for weekend tournaments. We live on the property in the main house coined the Brown House. You will have complete privacy, but you may see us around eating al fresco!

Guest favorite

Home in Ship Bottom

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

RATED AS LBI's BEST RENTAL - NEW

LONG BEACH ISLAND - New, 1 BLOCK TO OCEAN! - 3 bedroom, 2 bath, outdoor enclosed beach shower! 2-car garage, full laundry, gas fireplace, natural gas grille on private 2nd floor deck, 2nd grille on ground level. Impeccably maintained, natural light, and spacious. Restaurants and shops 1/2 block. Bagels, coffee and ice cream same block. Keurig & Cuisinart coffee makers. Exceptionally CLEAN. AIR PURIFIERS in all 3 Bedrooms. MIN 2 NIGHTS - off summer. MIN 5 NIGHTS - some summer weeks.

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Beach Haven

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Sunny, Delightful Apartment in the Heart of LBI!

Newly beautifully decorated, bright, sunny, delightful apartment in the heart of LBI. 2 flat screen TV's. Dining table + kitchen island with stools. New refrigerator, microwave, dishes, cookware & kitchen equipment. Dishwasher & washer/dryer. Central air. Private deck with patio table. Backyard with dining table. Outdoor shower. 2 night stay may be OK if 3 nights are not available on calendar. Discount for rental of multiple weeks. Looking forward to speaking with you!

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Dennis

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 340 reviews

Shore Cottage~minutes to beach, wine, brews

The Shore Cottage is a cozy one bedroom guest house with vaulted ceilings and abundant natural light nestled in quiet Ocean View - just 5 minutes from Sea Isle City beaches and less than 10 minutes from the beaches of Avalon & Stone Harbor. In addition to the beaches, Abbie Homes Estate, local breweries, wineries, and golf courses are within minutes of the Shore Cottage. Situated in a centrally located neighborhood, kick back and experience all that the shore has to offer.

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Galloway

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Dock side studio with water views!

This new one room studio sits inside the Edwin B Forsythe National Wildlife Refuge and is a bird watchers paradise with 366 species of birds observed and documented here.Look up Edwin B Forsythe and you will see info on the visitor center with walking trails.) Steps to a private dock for crabbing, fishing or your water toys. Tranquility abounds but close to AC, Brigantine, Historic Port Republic & Smithville Village!

Guest favorite

Houseboat in Lacey Township

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 253 reviews

Float and Relax ON the Water-Float Home w Kayaks!

✓ NO Cleaning Fee ✓ NO Guest Service Fee (usually 15%) Completely updated 1 bedroom Float Home on the beautiful Forked River! Enjoy a glass of wine for a sunset on your rooftop deck. Play, drink, and eat on the many party spots up and down the river. Fall asleep to the calming sound of water right outside your window. Awesome Lake Beach and Wibit only a mile away! Strong and fast WiFi! Kayaks included!!!

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Barnegat Township

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

New Private Suite 10 minutes from LBI !

This unique place has a style all its own. Located in a very nice and secure neighborhood 10 minutes away from the beautiful beach of Long Beach Island, 10 minutes away from the bridge and Hotel LBI, 20 minutes away from Pop Corn Park, 25 minutes away from Seaside Hights, 30 minutes away from Atlantic City, 30 minutes away from Great Adventure, 1:15 minutes from Philadelphia, 1:45 minutes from NYC.

Guest favorite

Home in Ship Bottom

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

LBI Ranch House, Walk to Beach and Everything!

**Wedding Parties: This home is 2 blocks to HotelLBI, 1 mile to Bonnet Island Estate, 2 miles to Mallard Island. Walk to Bonnet Island using guarded walkway. We provide made beds, linens and for the beach: badges, towels, chairs and umbrellas. This house is a classic raised ranch on pilings. It has modern conveniences and beach-y decor. The location is great (2.5 blocks or 1/4 mile to beach)