Cottage vacation rentals in LaGrange County

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in LaGrange County

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Cottage in Middlebury

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Stone Lake Cottage Middlebury IN Boat Fish getaway

Located on beautiful Stone lake in Middlebury, IN. Crafts Amish antique auction fish swim lake relaxing. Please bring bedding, towels, and personals/toiletries. 2 queens, 1 twin, 2 double beds. Includes 3 BR/4 baths (detached 3rd BR CLOSED in winter), room for 6-8, AC, Smart TV, streaming services , WiFi, fireplace, lake, pier, kayak, paddle boat, grill, fire pit, washer/dryer, dishwasher, toys for swimming, fishing, and 5 miles from Shipshewana/Middlebury. Min primary guest age is 21.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Shipshewana

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 74 reviews

Best sunsets from new covered deck

Enjoy our cozy, lake front cottage on Stone Lake. You are just off the I 80/90 toll road at exit 107. Quiet lake environment For winter rentals multiple month terms available inquire for non-posted rates. Winter sports in the area like skiing, ice skating, snowmobiling, ice fishing. We are only a half hour from Notre Dame, perfect for game days or campus visits. This cottage is wonderful for getaways and all season enjoyment. The new, covered front deck is a great spot for evening sunsets.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Howe

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 589 reviews

Cozy Nest - hot tub, pet friendly, fee free

The Cozy Nest is an adorable three-bedroom, pet-friendly cottage with amazing views of a quiet, no-wake lake. Enjoy the stunning view while your cares melt away in the hot tub. The kitchen is fully stocked and ready for your use. Fiber optic wifi will keep you connected. There are a two of bicycles available for exploring the surrounding countryside as well as a canoe, 3 kayaks, and paddle boat to use on the water. Shipshewana is a quick 15-mile drive away through beautiful Amish countryside.

Cottage in Shipshewana

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Bright Shipshewana Gem w/ Shuffleboard Table!

Discover your next rural escape to Indiana at this 1-bedroom, 1-bath Shipshewana vacation rental! As you step inside this unit, you can immediately enjoy an open and airy layout featuring entertaining amenities like a shuffleboard table. Visit the Menno-Hof Amish & Mennonite Museum to learn something new about the area's culture, get near the water at the Shipshewana Lake Park, or venture out to South Bend and explore the University of Notre Dame campus. Be sure to check out the on-site farm!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Wolcottville

5 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Cozy lakefront cottage in the ❤️ of Amish country!

Welcome to our cozy lakefront cottage on Atwood Lake. This is a quiet & fun fishing and swimming lake w/ access to the Indian Chain of Lakes (2 of which are ski lakes) just a 3 min drive away. Includes the use of 3 kayaks & paddle boat. There is a dock if you want to bring your own boat and room for your boat trailer. Has a walk in beachy area w/ sand for the kids to play. Enjoy the firepit to end the evening. Lots to do for year round fun. NO PETS, NO PARTIES AND NO SMOKING OF ANY KIND!!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Topeka

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Honeyville Cottage

Escape from the hustle of daily life in the heart of Amish country. Step into this quaint cottage and leave your worries at the door. Soak your cares away in the cast iron claw foot tub or relax on the patio watching the neighbors horses run. Bicycles are available for a stroll through back country roads. Play games around the kitchen table. Take a trip into town for fresh baked Amish goods, a traditional Amish dinner or shopping. At night you can grab a blanket and lay under the stars.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Orland

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Cozy cottage on peaceful lake

Enjoy relaxation, nature and fun on quiet Wall Lake. The clean, clear water offers great fishing (ice fishing in the winter), swimming, kayacking (provided), etc. with no fast or loud watercraft due to the 10 mph speed limit. Bring your own boat and put it in at the free, public access and then tie up at our own personal dock mere steps away from the house. A quiet, neighborhood street circles the lake and is perfect for strolls, including to the public beach or yummy Wall Lake Tavern.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Howe

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Peaceful, relaxing and cozy vintage style cottage

Nestled in the heart of Amish country, this charming cottage has everything you need for a relaxing getaway at the lake. Vintage style cottage features a private back yard with a fire pit, deck with a picnic table and grill for your enjoyment. Free firewood, two kayaks and canoe for boating on the no wake lake. The property is located across the street from the lake, it includes lake access and a shared pier. Visit Shipshewana and enjoy all this quaint small town has to offer.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Wolcottville

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews

Quaint, cozy lake front cottage on Westler Lake

Our lake front cottage is on our property as a guest house. You have access to kayaks, paddle boards, paddle boat, fire pit and floats. This cottage is newly rebuilt with a beautiful view of the lake. Boat dock available. If you have access to a boat, there are five lakes in the chain. You can be on the lakes for a couple of hours and never see the same thing. The bunk bed in the 2nd bedroom is two full beds. Clearance for top bunk is slim. Recommend children for top bunk.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Wolcottville

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Lakefront Getaway on Atwood Lake

Relax with the family at this peaceful Atwood Lake home. Close to Shipshewana, Indiana, heart of Amish Country. Visit the many parks in Lagrange County. After a small road trip, resign back at Atwood Lake to this beautiful shallow, white sandy beach. Enjoy kayaking, fishing, campfire and yard games with your family. Ready to use with full kitchen. We updated the patio furniture this year, it’s now blue! Start making your family memories now.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Wolcottville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Yoder's Catfish Cottage (Cozy Lakeside Cottage)

Cozy 3-bedroom (Adult only) cottage with amazing views of a quiet, no-wake Messick Lake. This is the perfect place to sit back and relax from your busy schedule. It is a small space ideal for no more than 4 people. A public access is available next door to launch a boat. This lake connects to two no-wake lakes and two sport lakes. Your agreement to the House Rules is required, under “Things to Know, House Rules and Additional Rules” must read.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Wolcottville

5 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

"Dock Holiday" on Oliver Lake

"Dock Holiday" is located at the end of a channel on prestigious Oliver Lake. Oliver Lake is known for being extremely clean and boasts being attached to the largest undeveloped lake in Indiana, Olin Lake. Oliver Lake is an all-sport lake from sunup to sundown. Bring your own boat and enjoy fishing, skiing, tubing, and multiple sandbars for swimming. We have a pontoon we rent out that is kept at Dock Holiday if you have interest.