Vacation rentals in Sanibel

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sanibel

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Saint James City

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Island Castaway--Free Kayaks

This is the perfect place to sit back, relax and enjoy the view. You have the privacy of a one-bedroom apartment with small kitchen and bath. We are close to great restaurants and some of the best music on the island. Open water and excellent fishing are minutes away. Two kayaks are set up for fishing and are available for guests to use so bring your fishing rod. Pine Island has no beachs, but Ft Myers Beach is about an hour away or take a ferry ride from Bokeelia to Cayo Costa for the day.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Saint James City

5 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Waterside Cottage

Enjoy our peaceful little island paradise nestled beneath sprawling oaks and scattered palms just minutes from St James City’s restaurants and bars. Just under 1/2 acre is yours to enjoy. Watch the manatees and dolphins swimming in the canal while you grill your catch of the day, or your fresh pick of the day from St James Fish House just down the street! Inside enjoy a fresh new contemporary and stylish cottage with everything you will need to make your stay comfortable, enjoyable and fun!

Guest favorite

Home in Fort Myers

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

So Beachy! A family and Pet-friendly Spacious Home

Welcome to SO Beachy!! We're finally back after Hurricane Ian, and this highly-rated property is better than ever! This family and pet friendly 1200 sqft home has been fully renovated and beautifully decorated, featuring everything you need to relax and enjoy our location that is within 5 miles of Sanibel, Fort Myers Beach, and Bunche Beach! Enjoy the beautiful sunsets on the beach and stay with us knowing you have all the beach supplies and basic necessities you could need for your stay!

Guest favorite

Home in Captiva

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

The Pearl Beach House, North Captiva Island,FL

This water-front property offers designer furniture and panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico throughout the home. Experience unprecedented privacy with direct walking access to the beach, and a very secluded location suitable for couples, friends or families. The property has a Main House and Guest Cottage, both with expansive decking and panoramic windows and doors providing spectacular views of the water and sunsets. StarLink WiFi and Samsung QLED smart TV. We allow dogs up to 50 lbs

Guest favorite

Condo in Saint James City

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Island Time Private Poolside Retreat !

Welcome to Island Time! Enjoy all that Pine Island has to offer from this comfy poolside, waterfront ground level apartment with private entrance and boat dock access. Enjoy lounging at the private pool or BBQing on the patio. 15 miles of bike/walking trails are accessible from the front door, and several waterfront tiki bars and restaurants are within walking distance. Captiva, Sanibel and Fort Myers Beach are a short boat ride away. Explore Cape Coral, Fort Myers and nearby state parks.

Guest favorite

Home in Fort Myers

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 317 reviews

Almost Sanibel, 5 min. Peace, Privacy & Nature.

Almost Sanibel is in a Peaceful/Quite neighborhood. Bunche Beach 2 miles, Sanibel Island 4 miles, Fort Myers Bch 5 miles. Home is set up as a duplex, with TWO COMPLETELY SEPERATE & PRIVATE entrances, kitchens, living rooms, bedrooms, bathrooms & laundry rooms for COMPLETE PRIVACY. It is a 2 bedroom with 2 King beds, 1 full bathroom & shower with large living room, kitchen & Lanie. Perfect for family or 2 couples! • 1/2 mile to Restaurants and Shopping • FREE High-Speed Wi-Fi and Cable-TV

Guest favorite

Home in Captiva

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Blue Laguna - Vacation in paradise!

Beautiful and welcoming are just two words to describe this magnificent, 4 story home with heated private pool and sweeping 360 degree water views from the observation deck. Blue Laguna features 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths allowing this home to sleep up to 6 people. Two screened in lanai's so you can sit and enjoy the island breeze and leave the sliding doors open for a true island nature experience during the colder seasons. A golf cart for 4 persons is also included in the rental.

Guest favorite

Home in Saint James City

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

2 Bedroom Island Oasis Getaway

Hi to all of our past & future guests. Our home is such a great place to stay, we are just steps from the water, fishing & the beautiful sunsets. We have space for your boat or you can rent ours. Completely remodeled home as of March 2022, there is a master bedroom and a 2nd bedroom along with a large bathroom. Guest will have access to the entire house including the lanai, patio, boat dock, boat ramp and parking. We also have an optional boat rental available to you right at the dock

Superhost

Home in Fort Myers

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 627 reviews

Tiny house next to Sanibel Island/ No cleaning fee

Tiny Paddle Board House $0 cleaning fee Stay on adventure's doorstep! 5 miles to FMB and Sanibel island (beaches, salt water fishing, paddle boarding, kayaking ). Are guests enjoy free amenities: 1. Coffee/tea/bottled water 2. Bicycles 3. SUP - inflatable paddle boards 4. BBQ gas grill 5. Beach chairs and umbrella 6. Cooler and beach towels 7. Secured Wi-Fi 8. Amazon TV, Netflix, Hulu, Disney +, ESPN+ 9. Parking 2 cars 10. Washer and dryer in house 11. Kids toys and books

Superhost

Condo in Sanibel

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Exquisite Beachfront Residence at Shell Island Bea

This is a one of a kind beachfront condo overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. A charming and beachy decor awaits in this sun-filled 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom condo with plush master quarters overlooking the ocean, renovated bathrooms with granite counter tops, upgraded kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a spacious guest bedroom featuring 2 comfy twin beds. Nestled within the unique Shell Island Beach Club, you're just a few feet away from Sanibel`s famous Lighthouse beach.

Superhost

Condo in Sanibel

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

“Wind + Tide” @ Island Beach Club, walk to beach!

Post Ian Update: We are now taking reservations at our My Sanibel Vacation website for Thanksgiving 2024 and beyond. We are excited to start welcoming guests back to the island! Please note that neighboring units and/or complexes may still be rebuilding from the hurricane. We will try to keep you updated but do expect some level of noise during your stay. Thanks for being part of our healing process and supporting the island! #SanibelStrong

Guest favorite

Rental unit in Cape Coral

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Private Apartment with sunny pool

One-bedroom plus den apartment attached to the main house with private entrance. The apartment has a small kitchenette for basic meal preparation. A large pool is right outside your door! Come relax by the pool & cool off on a hot day. The pool is for your private use. We have a gas BBQ grill located in the fenced yard for your use. Ft. Myers Beach 35 min away Sanibel Beach 45 min away Naples Beaches 60 min away